Argumentative Paper Topic

Chris Osgood: legendary goaltender, or the benefactor of one the most successful franchises in professional sports? Hockey fans have debated this question throughout Osgood's career. Now that he has hung up his pads, the hockey world has once again opened this debate. Fans and players alike argue over whether Osgood belongs in the Hall of Fame or owes his success to the Detroit Red Wings' reigning "dynasty." Osgood could never once shake the critics from his back, yet he continued to produce stellar numbers and won three Stanley Cups in his seventeen seasons in the National Hockey League. Many people in the hockey community attribute these feats to Osgood's legendary teammates. Others disagree and claim that without Osgood's talent and experience, Detroit might not have the same incredible track record. He can boast a historic number of career wins and shutouts. His rare skills in offensive plays and puck possession place him among an elite group of netminders. The formidable records he owns stand tall next to those of his fellow goaltenders already in the Hall of Fame. These numbers alone point to Osgood's candidacy on future ballots, but his involvement with the team over the years gives him an extra edge over the naysayers. His influence touches far more than the frustrated forwards who could never bury the puck behind the NHL's smallest goalie. With Osgood's constant support, guidance, and mentoring, the Red Wings' young first-string goaltender, Jimmy Howard, has quickly carved a place for himself as one of the league's rising stars. Additionally, from Osgood's new position as the team's goaltending development coach, Detroit's hopeful prospects can draw from his experience and grow in an encouraging environment. Osgood embodies both the winning machine who spits out compelling numbers and the team player who places his teammates before himself. This mixture of success and devotion makes him a well-rounded player, and this well-rounded legacy has earned him a spot in the hockey Hall of Fame.